Guarded Location: Choice-Based Fiction Structure

I’m currently partway through playing and analysing Paul Partington’s Temple of the Skull God, a 2024 independent gamebook. It’s the subject of this month’s 100 Endings Reading Club on Discord and I’m using it as the third test case for a structural analysis I’m developing. It’s a great gamebook, with a clear debt to Fabled Lands and the open-world structure, a pirates/mesoamerican setting with perhaps the occasional escapee from Isla Nublar thrown in. There’s an elegant game system, called GNAT, codewords, tickboxes, an inventory of themed items – and not too many, either – and above all, it’s fun. It’s an adventure gamebook, not a reader-punishment tool or a painful proof of concept!

But while I’m logging all the conditions and links, I’ve noticed a neat and very efficient little pattern that Paul has used to build his world. In a gamebook like this, there has to be some system to govern re-visiting locations, but also something to make them feel memorable and distinct from one another. He does it like this:

What you’ve got here is a three-passage conditional guarded location. You can reach the location from multiple other passages and when you arrive, the first thing you read is a tickbox query. This is empty by default, so on you read.

In this sort of location, the author has stationed some sort of guard – a monster, animal or character who attacks the reader. A simple combat check (often as simple as the one illustrated here) has two outcomes: death – in which case, the adventure is over and no outward link is needed – or victory – in which case the box at the head of the passage is ticked and the player sent on to a subsequent passage. This follower (labelled A.2 in the top diagram) can describe how the guard is overcome, any side-effect on the player and then provide them with some reward for overcoming the enemy – loot of some kind. This passage is then really an event bundled into the location, and the original passage, which is a combat, is an event passage masquerading as a location.

A.2 concludes with options to travel on – normally a spatial choice – and fits back into the network of navigational passages that form an open world.

However, when revisiting Location A, the tickbox, which indicates that the guard has already been overcome and that the loot is already plundered (that’s efficient!) diverts the reader from A.1 to A.3, which is a vanilla location passage without any event, but with the same exit options as A.2.

It’s not rocket science but I think the lock on accessing the loot behind the guardian combat and the smoothness of the tickbox check make this among the most efficient possible ways to introduce guarded locations into an open-world gamebook. Paul uses it about 9 times in a 573-passage book, so it doesn’t become obvious and repetitive, and there are a few variations.

Anyway, it’s certainly a little piece I’ll consider employing myself on my next adventure in this style. Steam Highwayman doesn’t tend to have guards hanging around waiting for you to kill them and take their loot, but it really suits any sort of exploration adventure or dungeon.

If you’re interested in some of my other gamebook structure analyses, you could take a look at this post from February 2025, when I was thinking about Fetch Quests (and writing them into Princes of the West.

Soberly Does It

God’s Word doesn’t only comfort us with promises of His love.

It also corrects and chastens us!

There are countless scripture journals available filled with cosy, encouraging meditations.  But are you ready to have your course corrected and your character refined?

I really rate Mark’s work, both for the vibrancy of his illustration and the seriousness with which he engages with Scripture.  He and Nina produced the wonderful Living and Powerful cards which we use with our family and at our home education hub.  They’re believing people who want God’s Spirit to guide them in their work and their personal lives.  And where has that brought them?

To produce SOBER!

If you’re ready to engage with God’s Word and to wrestle, like Jacob, until you receive what He has for you, then this really is a pledge for you.

—

Kickstarter isn’t easy.  Even if your work is good, it has to reach the people who value it and then it has to find them on a day when they can be convinced to support it.  My four Kickstarter campaigns have not made me rich, but they’ve taught me a lot.  I’ve had to soberly acknowledge that however hard I work on Steam Highwayman, it’s a niche product for a niche audience.

And my suspicion about SOBER is that it is also niche…  Not that the English-speaking, Christian demographic is small.  No – it’s the largest reading population on earth and it’s actually fairly-well represented on Kickstarter.  It’s just that as humans, we don’t look to have our preferences challenged or our desires shut down.  We’re creatures of comfort.  And many times, God’s Word is not there to pander to our comfort, but to improve us – even at times, top condemn the sin in us so that we can recognise it and repent of it.

For many Christians, it’s enough for this to happen once a week – or less frequently – on a Sunday morning, in a general sort of way.  But if you’re serious about your walk with Jesus, then that isn’t enough.  We need to have God’s Word in our faces and on our lips – because His word is life, is light and is truth, and there is no other way to know Him or to approach Him.

So what I wonder is, if God is prompting people like Mark and Nina to produce meditations on His Word that are meant to challenge us – for our good and so that He can work through us more fully – then how many people are willing to actually to participate with the work of His Spirit – to give Him a big ‘Yes’?  Just a few?

I’m in.  I haven’t seen all the illustrations.  I know and enjoy Cumi’s work already and I’m looking forward to opening this journal and letting a morsel of God’s Word jump out at me, enlivened by Mark’s beautiful and playful illustrations, and give me a hard time.  Because I know that my heart needs to be more like the heart of Jesus.

The Altimer – Gamebook Analysis

The 100 Endings Book Club on Discord is just finishing a month-long read-along of The Altimer by Samuel Isaacson. The book was Sam’s first gamebook, published in 2019, and has spawned two more books in the Entram Trilogy and several heterogeneous gamebooks since: check out Sam’s bibliography on Demian Katz’s ever-useful gamebook catalogue. I bought a copy of The Altimer and its sequels a few years ago, played it, had a few thoughts, dipped into its sequel and then shelved it. But when it came up for discussion in the Book Club, I told everyone I’d read along, in a public statement that I then had to make good – ie I had to make time for it or eat my words.

I’m not going to review the book here so much as analyse it: after another playthrough at the beginning of October, I decided I wanted to see how Sam had structured or built his piece. At only 300 passages, it isn’t a long book, and I’ve been working on building a set of metrics to help compare and analyse choice-based works for a while.

300 passages.

First of all, there is a single passage in the book without any Entrances or Exits. Discussion in the group tended towards classing this as a red herring – something that might catch the eye and offer the reader a false solution. It could also be an artefact of an earlier draft that escaped editing. It could be both.

The total number of options in the book is 501, giving a choice density of 1.82 – ie a mean average of 1.82 options for each passage. I haven’t anything else to compare with right now, but I feel that this is almost going to be the most important metric for quickly summarising or classifying choice-based fiction.

The longest possible path through the book will take you 130 passages – largely spent whiffling around the interior of the spaceship itself – and the shortest possible might be as low as 58, but I need to double-check that. A quick route through does imply replayability for the reader who is enjoying the book and wants to see what secrets are hidden down side-routes.

There are 23 other passages without Exits. One of these is the Victory passage – 300, in this case, paying homage to Fighting Fantasy’s ‘turn to 400’. 22 others are dead ends – ie places where your journey ends in failure. This suggests a simple metric that will help describe plenty of linear gamebooks: proportion of endings and deaths.

Could I call this metric ‘Terminality‘? I quite like that. Positive and negative terminality, clearly, and total terminality.

Including these ending passages, there are 127 that offer the reader no choice: there may be other interactions within the passage, such as collecting an item or codeword, but there is no final choice between alternative passages at the end of these passages. Hence 173 passages do offer more than one exit.

With 103 passages that send the read on without an option, I’d calculate a Linearity score of 34.33%.

The dispersal of options is interesting. Even more common than the ‘no-option’ direct-link passage is the classic dilemma: two opposing options. Many times in The Altimer these are opposites, whether spatial (like go left or go right down corridors) or action-type choices (like enter a door violently or sneak through it), but in many cases these are also a hybrid: make an action or move through the space – an action/spatial type that is not a clear dilemma.

The passages with 4 or exits tend to be spatial choices – in some cases, complicated by a conditional route out as well. Combat choices are dilemmas by nature: win, or lose. It’s either you or a floating purple bitey alien monster on the floor at the end of a few dicerolls, and there is no third way about it.

I’ve classified the main types of options like this:

  • spatial, ie options describing movement within physical space
  • social, ie options that influence relationships with other characters
  • action, ie options that describe the main character’s activity within the game

Then there are a few other types:

  • conditional, ie options decided by previous choices, usually marked by codewords, unique items or other flag markers
  • combat, where the passage’s exits are decided by a fight: this is a type of chance option
  • skill check, which is really another chance option, as the dice can always betray you
  • puzzle, which only occurs once in The Altimer. This is a real-world puzzle for the reader to solve, such as a magic square or code that does not depend upon in-game lore but upon the reader’s skill, knowledge and patience

Including those hybrid choices (such as Action/Spatial, and even a lone ‘Social/Spatial’, which gives you a choice to interact with a character or leave), the total here climbs higher than the number of passages with options. I think that’s interesting. It’s clear that spatial choices dominate the actual choosing part of the adventure, followed by your choice to do different things and then, interestingly, by the way you choose to interact with other characters.

But you can simplify the categories again into those options decided by chance, by previous choices (expressed as conditions), true choice, puzzle solving and passages without choice. There are more than 7 combats in the book, but only 7 of them decide your exit passage: this is something of an inconsistency across the book.

There’s more to say and think, but this will do for now: sharing it will, I hope, prompt some discussion!

I mean to complete another analysis on a similar-length gamebook soon – I have one in mind – and the comparison may be enlightening.

Anyway, a massive thanks and well-done to Sam for his work in this book. It was a great launch to his gamebook career and I know plenty of people think highly of it. I certainly have enjoyed thinking about it and reading it.

If you’d like to see my data in analysing the book, here you are.

If you’re thinking of buying a copy, let me make it easy for you: The Altimer.

And on Goodreads:

And on Gamebooks.org

Here is the final stat dump:

The Altimer – Sam Isaacson, 2019

Length: 300 passages

Terminality (total): 7.67%
” (positive): 0.33% (ie how many passages give you victory)
” (negative): 7.33% (ie how many passages kill you)

Linearity: 34.33% (ie 103 passages/300 send you onwards without giving you any options)
Choice density: 1.82 options/passage

Choosability: 47.67% (ie on 143/300 passages, you get to choose your option freely)
Conditionality: 13.67% (ie on 41/300 passages, previous choices decide your next passage)
Chance index: 6.33% (ie on 19/300 passages, dice or another random factor decide your next passage)

Puzzle density: 0.33% or 1/300. Watch out here, as Sam grows to love a puzzle over his next books.

Choice Types:
Spatial / Action / Social = 72/46/25 /300 or 24% Spatial choices / 15.33% Action choices / 11.67% Social Choices
(Note that spatial is almost exactly equal to the total of Action + Social. Ie this book is largely a spatial puzzle, with some social interactions and a fair amount of activity options.

The Reader’s Companion I-IV Now Available! (And Free)

I promised I’d update the Reader’s Companion for Steam Highwayman and I managed to complete it last week, so rather than wait until the next scheduled update, I wanted to post it here for free access.

What is the Companion?  It’s a printable character sheet / tickbox / codeword list combo document that allows you to:

  • keep your copy of Steam Highwayman clean and unmarked
  • keep different playthroughs recorded or separated
  • track the many variables without having to turn to the back of your book

I’ve produced it in two new versions – one that includes every tickbox and editable field from all four volumes of Steam Highwayman, perfect for a new playthrough with ambitions.  Then there’s a version that only duplicates the Princes of the West sheets – which is still around 12 pages – which might suit anyone with a longstanding playthrough which has already drained the first volumes.  The original 3-book companion is also still available for download.

All of them are here on my website.

An earlier version of the Companion can be seen on Dan Shaw’s Steam Highwayman table, which he kindly photographed for me a few days ago: you can see a playthrough in process right here!

Smog & Ambuscade playthrough by Dan Shaw

And what a playthrough it was. I quote (with permission) from our conversation (some spoilers removed): 

I befriended two locals who could help me, built hideouts in two woods, became a famed lawbreaker after going to prison for stealing a paychest, hit a wealth high point after opening a strongbox, and twice got beaten half to death robbing seven melons and a pineapple from a grand house and unwisely flashing the cash…

But my tale went downhill after unwisely killing a judge in a fit of righteousness. I decided to prematurely retire after about 15 hours’ play, with £26 4s to my name, 13 scars and 140 points total.

Perhaps you recognise some of the Smog & Ambuscade exploits alluded to in there?  Perhaps you too have suffered for your taste for tropical fruit?  It was that moment in our conversation that had me laughing – an unintended, emergent narrative of a highway robber returning again and again to rob a greenhouse, sell the fruit somewhere nearby (I don’t even remember who buys them!) and suffering for his hubris – it was that moment that really felt like the heart of the Steam Highwayman experience.

I’d love to hear more of the highs and lows of your adventures in the world: the moments that I wrote that really stood out for you, and the unintended odd bits created by the open-world system, like meeting the same person again and again or an odd juxtaposition of encounters that felt somehow right.  I’m hoping that some of these will be the stories that draw new readers in too.

As far as fulfilment goes, it’s still underway.  Thanks for the patience of everyone who has paid for their shipping and not yet received their complete rewards: some are in the post and some are being resent today.  Essentially, post-Brexit small shipments like these are not as simple as they used to be, and I’m doing my best.  I’ve received many, many emails from those of you awaiting rewards and arranging deliveries and I’d like to sincerely thank the entire community for their patience, politeness and understanding.  Amongst all these messages I haven’t received a single complaint or rude word, only support and encouragement: it makes this all much easier for me!  

I have to be upfront and let you know that now that the main part of the project is completed and I’m simply handing shipping and fulfilment, I’m not able to devote as much time to the project as previously.  I have other things to do (some of which help pay the bills!) that demand my time, so in some cases you’ve had to wait up to a week for a reply to a query or an email.  I’m still able to give most Mondays to the project, so expect a reply or update then if you’re waiting for your packages or to hear more.  I’m about to work through the current backlog after posting this update.

So I wish each of you happy adventuring and I’ll aim to update again here in a fortnight – unless something exciting happens first!

Next update due: 5.10.26

Update 34: Further Fulfilment Progress

I know, that’s a catchy title, isn’t it?

I’ve just completed another small batch of shipping orders and prepared a set of reward packages for posting, bringing me up to date.  Together with a double-check of the payment records, I’m confident that everyone who has paid for the shipment of their rewards has now either received them or has them in the post! This brings me to:

255 / 313 or 81% book shipments ordered

217/ 237 or 92% map and guidebook packages posted

One of the biggest issues of my payment system is that I haven’t always matched payments with your backer details.  This has happened when a different email account to your Kickstarter email has been used and I’ve done my best to follow this up when I can identify you by other means.  However, in a few cases it has led to delayed shipments – I apologise for that.  I think these could have been avoided.

Fulfilment has been a bit trickier than I hoped and it’s taken longer too.  The financial viability of the project has always depended on printing the books regionally, but with the loss of European printing, this has really changed the shipping situation for Europe.  In previous Kickstarters – which were also pre-Brexit – tariffs were lower and the shipping route was a lot more predictable.  I’m having to deal with many more returned packages and other disruptions – but almost exclusively with the European shipments.  Elsewhere, things are going smoothly.  So I’d like to thank all you European backers – which includes among you some of my earliest and most committed readers – for your patience.

It also seems that the tracking emails from the printer/distributor IngramSpark are a bit unreliable.  All the tracked shipments do generate tracking details and where you’ve paid for them, I’ve used your email as a reference, but these don’t always seem to arrive – or if they do, they get spam-classed.  So do ask – I can use a back route with my account with Ingram to retrieve them – and I’ve had to do this to chase up several parcels across the world.

If you haven’t yet received anything and you paid for your shipping before September, please let me know, ideally in reply to my emails from steamhighwayman at gmail.com.  You can respond here on Kickstarter but just be aware that it can take me a while to get time to log in and check through comments and messages.  Either way, I can then check for you and we can carry on via email.

I also attended Fighting Fantasy Fest 6 in West London last week and it was a joy and a privilege to see so many of you in the flesh.  Around 30 backers collected their rewards in person, so that was a big step forward.  But it was also a blast.  I was chatting and comparing notes with Ken Boyter on the table next to me for most of the day.  He was selling his new gamebook To Kill a Thief and had an enviable greatcoat – mine went mouldy some years ago.  If you want a flavour of the whole event, there’s Jon Green’s great video here in which Ken and I did a giggly double-act at Jonathan’s expense, and then there’s Gil Jugnot’s charmingly breathless and excited video here, translatable from French through the wonders of youtube, making his waterfall of narration more-or-less intelligible.

There are a couple of other hand-deliveries and collections to make in the next few weeks, which will lower my stock of books I’m holding here in the flat.  However, I estimate I’ll still have about 15 boxes of map packets when this is all done!  I’ll have to find somewhere dry and safe to store these, either to sell through my site over the next couple of years or to reserve for the next Kickstarter…

Where from here:

Clearly there’s a bit of following-up with backers to do, but some of this is now in your court: if you haven’t yet paid for shipping, please do as soon as you can.  There should have been at least two emails to the account you registered with the campaign – although it is possible they got spam-classed – and all the details are in there.  I recognise that this means there will be a long tail to this project and it may be several months before I can rejoice that the final reward package is shipped or ordered.  Pity my family, who still have a pile of boxes in the living room!

I have some more Collections and drop-offs to arrange, particularly amongst friends and family who supported the project.  These will be a nice chance to share the new book too.

I mean to complete the new Steam Highwayman Companion fairly soon, which can be printed off to allow you to play the books without marking them.  The old one (for books 1-3) is here – although there are a couple of missing pieces I’ll also be correcting.  A couple of people have already asked about this and when it’s done you’ll all receive a copy by email – and I’ll then post it on my website with the other Steam Highwayman resources.  Perhaps this’ll make a nice printed reward for the next Kickstarter…

Because, yes, a part of my brain is already thinking about the next books and the next Kickstarter.  But let’s leave that for now.

I also have to put a good bit of time into marketing the new book, ensuring that previous backers who missed their chance to join in with this campaign get a chance to add Princes of the West to their collection.  This will probably coincide with quite a bit of work on my website, so if you’re a follower there, expect some changes.  If you’ve not yet taken a look, please have a rummage around: I’ve got material on how the Steam Highwayman books were inspired and produced going right back to the beginning, together with other bits and bobs you might find interesting.

And the mini-adventures are pressing hard against my conscience.  I’m actually really looking forward to creating these – something shorter but perhaps more concentrated than the big books – like little shots of Steam Highwayman goodness.  One reason I haven’t got further with them yet is that I haven’t yet worked out how much of the Steam Highwayman game system they need to include.  They will probably be linear rather than open-world, so I may not have to include exploration, pursuit, large shops, arrest and punishment and maybe not even random encounters…  So what should I include?  It really gets me thinking.  If they work, I may write a lot of them.  There are a couple more hinted at in Princes of the West, if you’ve taken a trip down to the Atmospheric Union Airfield…

So watch out for another email with the new Player’s Companion – hopefully before the next update.

Next update due: 28.9.26

Update 31 – Princes of the West Fulfilment Imminent!

TLDR:

  • Princes of the West ready for fulfilment
  • Shipping payment and address update email to follow
  • Backer Order shipping
  • Stretch Goal stories will happen… just not yet.

In the last update I listed jobs to do and, despite the heat, two god-daughters staying with us for a week, an overnight trip to the airport and four small children to entertain and provide for, I managed to hit them all.  Crucially, the acknowledgements were finished and final edited files for Steam Highwayman: Princes of the West were uploaded to IngramSpark.  A single copy is now on rush production as a final (I hope) print proof.  Since the last copy produced some weeks ago there have been hundreds of tiny changes and a few big ones – all improving gameplay, clarity and consistency.  Phew!

That means that I can begin fulfilling your rewards.  I dropped the fourth map from the Touring Guide – it was taking too long to produce and did not significantly add to the gameplay – and now have all the parts to assemble the map packs.  The Adventurers’ Logs are complete too and I have packaging to ship these around the world.

In the next few days I will also correct outstanding errata in Smog & Ambuscade, Highways & Holloways and The Reeking Metropolis so that anyone who has ordered these will get them in the best possible state.

I’ve spent a lot of time on shipping and the original plan is still the cheapest and in the majority of cases my shipping estimates were good.  In most cases your physical rewards will travel as two shipments – this is still the cheapest option, as the maps have to travel from the UK (print-on-demand not an option for these) and the books can be printed in the US, UK or Australia.  In some cases (especially Singapore, Malaysia and Hong Kong) I’ll need to send a single package from the UK.

In the next few days I will be emailing backers by country with links to pay for shipping.  Prices vary by region and also depending on whether you backed just for the books or for books and extras, but I will detail it all in the email.  Up-to-date addresses will be gathered with payments.

I will do my best to fulfil the books in Backer Order – as long as I have your shipping payment and address.  If you have ordered a Custom Wanted Poster Frontispiece but haven’t yet provided an image, you will have to wait until you do.  In a few cases I will make shipments to single countries in one go (eg Singapore).

I can manage about 20 shipments a day, but there are interruptions and I do have other commitments over the summer, so the majority of your rewards will be on their way by the end of August.  Please be patient with me – it’s a huge job and not one that I actually take any payment for personally.

Remember, if you can wait until 5 September and are attending Fighting Fantasy Fest 6 (the premier gamebook convention), then you can avoid any shipping charge, meet me there and collect your reward in your hand.  It’d be great to see you: just fill in this form or indicate in response to the shipping email.

And the stretch goals?  Well, these were a stretch!  You got a stretched book (it increased by about 400 sections after the Kickstarter!) but you will get Harvest of Death and Dark Satanic Mills as well…  When they’re written and done.  I’m looking forward to writing these as little standalones but with all the benefit of the improvements I’ve made to Princes.

I probably won’t update on here until towards the end of the shipping process – I’ll be working by email with you personally where necessary and working through the batch of boxes etc – so expect that email and expect another update on here towards the end of August.

Next update due: 26.8.26

Update 30: Princes of the West now fully edited – wow!

Steam Highwayman: Princes of the West

Late on Tuesday night I completed the final corrections and edits to Steam Highwayman IV: Princes of the West.  Final tweaks included standardising a key character’s accent, which was amusing.  She started off a bit too proper and by the end of the book I was writing her in proper Wes’ cunn’ry aaczent so I had to find all the instances of her speech and westify them.  I also wrote a couple of last-minute additions – a sequence that allows you to close up one of the major quests in a more on-stage manner and an encounter with a strange man in a new location, high on Dartmoor.  That was an interesting one – but I’ll write about it another time.  Today you get more news.

That was the key target for the fortnight so reaching it is a big success.  I also completed the Touring Guide and the large maps, so these were sent to the printers…  As were the files for the previous maps and Touring Guide.  These all arrived over the last few days – 28 boxes of printing.

Some of your rewards arrived at my flat on Monday. The A2 flatpacks each contain 250 maps.
And here is the other half of the shipment, arrived on Tuesday. 19 boxes of booklets and folders for the Touring Guides.

I already had the Adventurer’s Logbook printed (three more boxes by my bedside. The only outstanding rewards are now the smaller A4 maps for the new Touring Guide: I have to complete the titling and superimposition of troop movements on the map of the Siege of Tintagel, and then I’ll order the A4 maps too.

The Adventurer’s logbook looks nice in the sunshine too.
Some of the many, many quests to undertake, all graded by difficulty.

The living room is now piled with boxes.  Over the next few weeks, my wife and I will be folding maps and assembling the Touring Guides.  With a nice show on (Ludwig returns in August…) and the children asleep, it’s actually a very pleasant job.

So where does that put the project?  I haven’t had the time to finalise shipping costs to Europe, so that is the next priority.  Once that is done (perhaps before the next fortnightly update), I’ll be sending out postage costs collecting postage payments.  I may delay this for the very beginning of August or may get to it before then.

I also have to complete the Acknowledgements section at the rear of the book – your featured spot, dear backers!  This can take a little while (it isn’t simply a list of names), but once that and a fresh blurb are done for the cover, the book will be complete.  I will certainly be ordering another print proof and then I will get moving with shipments.

Thanks for staying with me all this way.  The book is a great adventure – as are the previous ones – and seeing it and the accompanying paratexts in solid form is deeply exciting.

PS – I suspect there are more of you attending Fighting Fantasy Fest 6 on 5 September than have yet said so.  If you are, you will be able to collect your pledge with no postage to pay – but only if you tell me!  If you’d like to collect at FFF6 and you haven’t yet let me know, please use this form.  So far I’ve only got 8 out of 330 backers collecting.  And let me tell you, collection is also a lot simpler for me!

Next fortnight’s jobs:

  • Complete final postage costs
  • Create postage payment links for each region/country
  • Complete acknowledgements
  • Re-write blurb
  • Chase outstanding Wanted Poster images
  • Complete final A4 map
  • Order A4 maps
  • Order packaging for extras

Next update due: 30.7.26

Update 29: Wheels of Cheese and some Essextraordinary Shenanigans coming up

Well, the first-ever print copy of Princes of the West arrived on Saturday and I still can’t quite believe it.  The colour is bright, bold and… physical!  In fact, the size and weight of the entire book is one of the things that is impressing me the most.  After more than two years of existing in some digital form or other and after almost ten years as a title, the book now has a physical form.

I’ve begun a playthrough of Princes and I’ve been having a great time.  Fine-tuning mechanics like damage, repair, fleeing from the Constables and selling loot have all really added to the core gameplay loop and it now feels like the reader is more a dark, mysterious figure of ambush than ever.  But there are also the classic Highwayman challenges: I’ve succesfully located victims, impersonated a Constable to get them to stop, beaten them in a duel, robbed them and then set off back to my hideout…  But with a couple of unlucky rolls, I’ve then had Constables on my tail – in an airship, no less – and then crashed my velosteam and been taken up.

But your adventure doesn’t end there.  There is a long quest sequence to occupy you the first time you are arrested and subsequent shorter ones and so far I haven’t been notorious enough to merit hanging…  So I escaped from gaol once, served one term and, in my playthrough, am currently back on the road with a couple of debuffs and a steep hill to climb to get back up to where I want to be.  But my hideout is still stuffed with items and I have reliable friends and good revenue avenues to explore among the smugglers.  And a nice cheese-trading route I found.

The cheese-trading route is something I want to tell you about.  Steam Highwayman is carefully plotted, but as an entire book it is more of an environment containing stories rather than a single narrative.  That means that although there are characters and quests that you can enjoy, much of your tale is really an emergent narrative that proceeds from ingredients in the game system.  So, for example, I have a strong trading system across the book with around 100 items traded in 50 locations at variable prices.  Local supply and narrative causality demand that the prices are lower in places and that means that occasionally, just occasionally, it is possible to make a profit with entirely honest trading.

In previous books this has occurred – sometimes less-carefully – and it has sometimes been criticised as a bug or at the very least as an exploit – but because of the travel mechanics I use, it is very rare that these sales are totally risk-free.  So, in my wheel of cheese example – I noticed, while visiting an industrial area in the south of the map, that the sale price of a wheel of cheese was pretty high – presumably because of all the workers demanding good, nourishing home food and the fact that no-one there has the time to make their own cheese.  In fact, that rang a faint bell and I think I probably chose that price with exactly that justification.

In the next few places I visited, I kept my eyes open in the markets but didn’t find cheese available at a price lower than that sale price in the industrial location.  But when I ventured to North Devon, I found a place that sold wheels of cheese at a great price – I could make a healthy profit on each one I carried.  So I did what any self-respecting road pirate would do – jettisoned cheap and unnecessary equipment, hid the good stuff and bought as many cheeses as I could strap aboard my vel.

All was going well as I rode south in the Devon sunshine.  Birds singing, cows mooing, Constables tipping their hats to honest cheese salesmen – when I encountered a weird, folkloric event that tossed a spanner into the works.  I ended up crashing my velosteam badly and while the cheese was okay, my Ferguson was leaking steam and barely running.  I made it to my destination, limping along on partial pressure, and sold the cheese, but then had to find somewhere to mend the machine. I didn’t want to risk going far, so I found a nearby repairman… whose high prices swallowed nearly all my cheese profit.  I had made a few shillings and left all my good stuff at the other side of the county.

And I laughed.  Because, frustrating though it was, this was exactly the kind of ‘partial success’ that makes a good story.  Duncan Thomson has a gamebook underway in which dicerolls explicitly lead to success, failure and partial or flawed success, and it’s something I’ve been thinking about a lot.  There have been other big wins in the playthrough – a visit to the roadside fair with some lovely prose, a pretty girl and a stat buff – a big sale of my first smuggled firkin of liquor allowing me to buy much-needed customisations for the vel – the escape, by the skin of my teeth, from an island prison – but it is the partial successes that really make me feel like I’m inhabiting something.  Another velosteam crash left me with two wasted firkins of whisky and a spoiled quest.  An accident while labouring with a steam-chisel in a prison quarry left me with a wound and a heavy Ability debuff, meaning my character is going to become dependent on those powerful pink pills if I want to regain my prowess.  I snuck into the Constable’s store to regain my confiscated equipment, but when I got there…  ah, I won’t spoil that one for you!

Steam Highwayman isn’t just about the stories I have written in it – it creates stories as you choose within this explorable environment.  That’s why I love an open-world gamebook – or an open-world game.  From Pirates! Gold to Fable Lands, Skyrim to GTA, I love how our experience turns events – even randomly generated ones – into coherent stories – so long as the world is well-crafted.

And speaking of craft, I’ve put a lot of time into smoothing out the first few hours of gameplay in Princes.  I have another set of edits to put into the files and mean to continue with the playthrough and other checks for at least another fortnight.  I’ve also had some more feedback on the introduction to the book, spent a lot of time working on shipping costs and been drawing some illustrations for the Guide.

Here’s the Old Devon Inn – the Princes analogue of the Old Exeter Inn in Ashburton.  I haven’t actually been there – I couldn’t fit it in on our tour of the west last September – but it is still a bucket list.  I mean, they have a painting of one of my great heros on the wall outside!

And on Sunday I won’t be serving at my church but attending the League of Essextraordinary Gentlemen’s Steampunk Shenanigans at the East Anglian Railway Museum at Earl’s Colne, near Colchester.  It’ll be my first steampunk event for a year, but a group that I know and like and a location I really enjoy.  I’ll be reading – it’ll be the very first reading from Princes – and selling books to the unsuspecting steampunk and non-steampunk public.  See you there?

I’ve made progress on the map of Tintagel; scrubbed the map of Plymouth (I didn’t like drawing it) and re-organised the passages for Plymouth in the book so you won’t need a map; sketched out another map to replace it; drawn two guide illustrations (at least 1 more needed); continued the codeword check; priced about half of the shipping.

In the next fortnight I will:

  • complete proofing the print and create a final edit of Princes of the West!
  • complete the Touring Guide and order the prints!
  • complete the maps and order them too!
  • finalise shipping costs!

Next update due: 16.7.26

Update 28: Print Proof Ordered

Now we’re really steaming.  I completed all the corrections earlier this week and I’ve uploaded the first digital files to Ingram so that I could order a print proof.  It should arrive in the next couple of weeks and you’ll be treated to a photo of me holding it in the next update, if all goes well.

Here’s a screenshot of the print order.  You can see that the print cost of the book implies a large volume…  We’re looking at 438 pages and 2250ish passages.

The book isn’t quite finalised – there are a few gameplay edits still pending, but I want to have a think about these while turning the real pages, and I’ll take the time to have a playthrough as well.  You can always catch a few more errors in print too.

However, having digital files ready is a crucial catalyst for the project: it allows me to get a final print cost and book size and weight, which I need to proceed with the shipping preparations.  I’ll explain more soon, but rather than use the Kickstarter pledge manager, I’m going to be collecting shipping costs directly through Stripe.  It means I can tailor the costs a lot more finely, hopefully keeping shipping to a minimum for all of us!  I’ve begun looking at the costs and overall it seems my estimates were fairly good, despite the time that has passed.

But there is one particular shipping option I want to draw your attention to: collection.  The final costing of the book and extras has shown that the project is within budget and therefore then there is nothing more to pay if you collect your rewards.  When and where?  Howabout at Fighting Fantasy Fest 6, on Saturday 5th September, in London, UK?

If you haven’t been, the Fest is the premier convention devoted exclusively to gamebooks – including, of course, the Fighting Fantasy series.  However, it has also become a haven for the independent authors of the gamebook renaissance and a great place to meet heros of the medium both past and present.  It’s organised by the stalwart Jon Green whose work bridges both the original Fighting Fantasy books and modern independent gamebooks.  What a legend.

COLLECTION FORM

If you mean to be there, then use this form to register to collect your rewards in person.  Please try and use the same email that you used for your pledge so that I don’t lose your response!  

If you can’t make it to the convention but would like to arrange collection in London, UK on a date following 5th September, just put a note in the form.

Otherwise, I’ll be sending out links to collect shipping payments and arrange final addresses in about a month for everyone who wants their rewards delivered to their door.  I’ve put a lot of work into shipping costs but they aren’t quite finalised yet.

It was late last year when I first wondered if this was all going to come together in time for FFF6 and I’m pleased to say that I’m on schedule for a complete set of physical rewards by then.  The extra adventures may take a little longer or may also be ready in time – I’m not sure.

So what else needs doing?  Here’s a longer list of the remaining jobs of the project.

– Acknowledgements

– Complete 2 maps (Plymouth and the siege of Tintagel)

– Write short adventures (Dark, Satanic Mills and Harvest of Death) 

– Complete shipping estimates and plan

– Digital decorations for boxes, frames etc

– Look over / improve character sheets

– Codeword check (partly done!)

– Create companion (partly done)

– Order maps

– Complete Touring Guide 2 (about 20 pages to do)

– Draw pubs (at least 3 to draw)

– Order guide folders

– Order guidebooks

– Assemble folders

– Order packaging

– Assemble TG2s

– Order TG1s

– Assemble TG1s

– Chase Wanted Posters

– Create remaining wanted posters

– Set up stripe links for shipping payments

– Update SH1-3 companion

– Update SH1

– Update SH2

– Update SH3

– Update errata

In the next fortnight I’ll be keenly awaiting that print proof, doing the taxes for my wife’s small company (an home education hub) and trying to survive in the heat.  I may get to the drawing of the maps or work on the guide – pretty much all of the remaining jobs are pleasant ones and I’m not pressurising myself now.

What’s in the Steam Highwayman’s tankard?  A pint of Marston’s Pedigree.

Next update due: 2.7.26

Update 26: Editing Going Well

I’ve just managed to put two full days into editing Princes of the West and it is exciting to feel the draft nearing a finished state.  I’ll give you a window into the process…

I sat down on Monday at around 9am – after tidying away breakfast for the family – and began to work on the Introduction.  These pages take a lot of focus – they need to be clear while setting the atmosphere, cover all the crucial systems while not boring a player.  For some readers, they’re the first thing they encounter – for others, they’re a reference to find answers for rule queries.  Some of you will no doubt skip them, having played Steam HIghwayman before – and then have to return to them to see what exactly they say about the Devon Music Tour…

It took me most of the day to get the Introduction how I wanted it.  I also corrected some small issues at the front of the book – typos in the copyright section, a missing icon on one of the maps – while crunching celery and raw carrot to stave off my sugar craving.  I incorporated a change to the combat rules that I hope will make fights less punishing after a recommendation from one of you with a background in statistics and responded to a set of thoughts from the first playtesters who saw the draft in April and May 2025.

I’ve begun an investigation into strange grey lines that accompany some of the spot illustrations…  These are pesky, spoiling the monochrome clarity of the pages, and unpredictable.  Why do they appear in some places and not others?  I’m not sure yet – but they also turned up in the previous print of The Reeking Metropolis, so I think they’re an artefact of the conversion into pdf…

While pursuing this, I began formatting the acknowledgements section of Princes – and would have liked to simply copy and paste the formatting from Metropolis – except that – now I reveal a secret – I lost the print-ready .pub file of The Reeking Metropolis some time ago…  The version I have is some way off the final printed version, with errors, placeholder images and no paratexts at the back – including acknowledgements.  That’s one reason I haven’t released an errata and revised edition of The Reeking Metropolis before now.  All my searches on the old laptop – and my various googledrives – turned up blank.

But with the focus of a sunny Monday morning and an empty house (my wife and children had left to go to a home-education meetup), a faint bell rang in my head…  Didn’t I use a USB stick for a while?  I dug around to see which ones I could find and unearthed a few from odd places – bedside drawer, spare wire pot, spare board-game-piece box.

And there amongst teaching resources was SH3.5 – and my heart leapt with gratitude and joy!  I’d just read the parables of the lost sheep, the lost coin and the lost son in Luke’s Gospel to my children, so I had to rejoice.  And make multiple copies of the file.

I’ll be releasing a tidier errata list for all previous volumes of Steam Highwayman when I fulfil this project as well as making sure any corrections are incorporated in newly-printed versions.

And many of you actually backed The Reeking Metropolis and are named in the acknowledgements.  So – here’s an important point – unless you tell me otherwise, each backer will be acknowledged in the book by: previously-chosen backer name; or Kickstarter provided name.  That’s the plan, anyway.

I’ve messaged those of you who are looking to have a Wanted Poster created as a frontispiece for your book (s) and already received the first image in reply – a fearsome, but somewhat foppish, Italian claimant to the title of the Steam Highwayman.  If anyone is thinking of the upgrade, it’s not too late.  I think these are a great way to personalise your books.

And among the corrections I completed was an inconsistency in the naming of the Cornish revolutionaries.  You know how those splinter groups are – barely able to agree on a name, let alone a coherent policy – but in this case I still had fragments of older names betraying my own struggle to give them a name.  Were they to be the Free Defenders of Kernow, or the Defenders of Free Kernow?  I even found myself referring to them as the Free Forces of Kernow at one point.  And then there is the tin of fruit / tinned fruit fiasco.  Boy oh boy.

That’s about one day’s work, finishing at 5pm.  Then on Tuesday I began at a similar time and focused on the main gameplay passages, screwing myself into the seat until I had reached 500 of the 2250 or so…  The sort of mistakes in here varied from typos (nice and easy) to missing passages…  For example, passage 147 was entirely absent from the draft but I reckoned I had written it as I had a vague memory of some of the dialogue.  I found it in the gdoc draft, pasted it in, matched the formatting, shuffled nearby passages, removed whitespace, replaced larger spot illustrations with smaller ones, renumbered the page tops and sighed in relief that I hadn’t needed to increase the page count.  Then there was a broken link that sent me back to the very first part of Princes I planned and wrote in October 2023.  Images follow.

The notebook is labelled up for reference, so I found it exactly where it should be and found the original flowchart/network sketch – with annoying gaps in the numbering.  But I was able to reconstruct and correct the flow.  This is a location that can be reached from two directions and can bounce the player back the way they came, but in the interest of saving passages I used a noted passage mechanic to identify the direction of travel…  It was all such a good plan except that at 278 I had instructed a player Wanted by the Haulage Guild to proceed directly to…  278.  Doh!

There was a passage I had already passed dealing with the event, but it spat the player out in the wrong direction…  And oh yes, another passage with the right orientation.  Phew.  Plug it in.

The other day on the Discord chat someone came to me with a broken link – they knew it was possible to meet acrobats somewhere in Smog & Ambuscade because I referred to the encounter in later books – and in fact I’ve used the codeword you gain early in the main quest of Princes – but they couldn’t see how to get there.  I investigated and discovered that back when editing Smog, around a decade(!!) ago, I had cut a link to save passages – and inadvertently isolated the acrobat encounter, meaning that no-one has ever been able to honestly access it and gain either the fun codeword or the NIMBLENESS +1 bonus…  Doh!

Needless to say, I’ll be fixing that.

These wiring issues are almost unavoidable in my writing process.  I track my ins and outs and links as best I can but I have to recognise that my method is not infallible.  Another reason I’m so grateful for the help provided by readers and playtesters.

I’m sometimes recommended software to try and write in, but even a platform as resilient as Twine struggles with a 1000+, let alone a 2000+, gamebook with the density of variables I use.  I’ve certainly improved since writing Smog and I’ve realised that modelling sections on paper is the most reliable thing I can do…  So the next two books should be easy to write, eh?  And have no errors.

I also began work on the final map that will be included in the Touring Guide – a map of Plymouth – so that feels nice.  2 of the 4 are complete.  There’s a bit more drawing to do for the guide itself, particularly some pub illustrations.  But I’m certainly nearing the end of this phase.

Which will give me chance to get to the standalone adventures I’m still aching to write – Harvest of Death and Dark Satanic Mills.  I had originally thought I could do these while the book was out with playtesters but that hasn’t been how it has worked!  You’ll get them, don’t worry.  I’ve even referenced two other standalone adventures buried in Princes – they’ve been spotted by at least one eagle-eyed playtester.

What next?

  • More editing of the main text
  • More work on the Guide maps
  • Writing of acknowledgements
  • Creation of the first Wanted Posters

Next update due: 5.6.26