
The 100 Endings Book Club on Discord is just finishing a month-long read-along of The Altimer by Samuel Isaacson. The book was Sam’s first gamebook, published in 2019, and has spawned two more books in the Entram Trilogy and several heterogeneous gamebooks since: check out Sam’s bibliography on Demian Katz’s ever-useful gamebook catalogue. I bought a copy of The Altimer and its sequels a few years ago, played it, had a few thoughts, dipped into its sequel and then shelved it. But when it came up for discussion in the Book Club, I told everyone I’d read along, in a public statement that I then had to make good – ie I had to make time for it or eat my words.
I’m not going to review the book here so much as analyse it: after another playthrough at the beginning of October, I decided I wanted to see how Sam had structured or built his piece. At only 300 passages, it isn’t a long book, and I’ve been working on building a set of metrics to help compare and analyse choice-based works for a while.
300 passages.
First of all, there is a single passage in the book without any Entrances or Exits. Discussion in the group tended towards classing this as a red herring – something that might catch the eye and offer the reader a false solution. It could also be an artefact of an earlier draft that escaped editing. It could be both.
The total number of options in the book is 501, giving a choice density of 1.82 – ie a mean average of 1.82 options for each passage. I haven’t anything else to compare with right now, but I feel that this is almost going to be the most important metric for quickly summarising or classifying choice-based fiction.
The longest possible path through the book will take you 130 passages – largely spent whiffling around the interior of the spaceship itself – and the shortest possible might be as low as 58, but I need to double-check that. A quick route through does imply replayability for the reader who is enjoying the book and wants to see what secrets are hidden down side-routes.
There are 23 other passages without Exits. One of these is the Victory passage – 300, in this case, paying homage to Fighting Fantasy’s ‘turn to 400’. 22 others are dead ends – ie places where your journey ends in failure. This suggests a simple metric that will help describe plenty of linear gamebooks: proportion of endings and deaths.
Could I call this metric ‘Terminality‘? I quite like that. Positive and negative terminality, clearly, and total terminality.
Including these ending passages, there are 127 that offer the reader no choice: there may be other interactions within the passage, such as collecting an item or codeword, but there is no final choice between alternative passages at the end of these passages. Hence 173 passages do offer more than one exit.
With 103 passages that send the read on without an option, I’d calculate a Linearity score of 34.33%.
The dispersal of options is interesting. Even more common than the ‘no-option’ direct-link passage is the classic dilemma: two opposing options. Many times in The Altimer these are opposites, whether spatial (like go left or go right down corridors) or action-type choices (like enter a door violently or sneak through it), but in many cases these are also a hybrid: make an action or move through the space – an action/spatial type that is not a clear dilemma.
The passages with 4 or exits tend to be spatial choices – in some cases, complicated by a conditional route out as well. Combat choices are dilemmas by nature: win, or lose. It’s either you or a floating purple bitey alien monster on the floor at the end of a few dicerolls, and there is no third way about it.
I’ve classified the main types of options like this:
- spatial, ie options describing movement within physical space
- social, ie options that influence relationships with other characters
- action, ie options that describe the main character’s activity within the game
Then there are a few other types:
- conditional, ie options decided by previous choices, usually marked by codewords, unique items or other flag markers
- combat, where the passage’s exits are decided by a fight: this is a type of chance option
- skill check, which is really another chance option, as the dice can always betray you
- puzzle, which only occurs once in The Altimer. This is a real-world puzzle for the reader to solve, such as a magic square or code that does not depend upon in-game lore but upon the reader’s skill, knowledge and patience
Including those hybrid choices (such as Action/Spatial, and even a lone ‘Social/Spatial’, which gives you a choice to interact with a character or leave), the total here climbs higher than the number of passages with options. I think that’s interesting. It’s clear that spatial choices dominate the actual choosing part of the adventure, followed by your choice to do different things and then, interestingly, by the way you choose to interact with other characters.
But you can simplify the categories again into those options decided by chance, by previous choices (expressed as conditions), true choice, puzzle solving and passages without choice. There are more than 7 combats in the book, but only 7 of them decide your exit passage: this is something of an inconsistency across the book.
There’s more to say and think, but this will do for now: sharing it will, I hope, prompt some discussion!
I mean to complete another analysis on a similar-length gamebook soon – I have one in mind – and the comparison may be enlightening.
Anyway, a massive thanks and well-done to Sam for his work in this book. It was a great launch to his gamebook career and I know plenty of people think highly of it. I certainly have enjoyed thinking about it and reading it.
If you’d like to see my data in analysing the book, here you are.
If you’re thinking of buying a copy, let me make it easy for you: The Altimer.
And on Goodreads:
And on Gamebooks.org
Here is the final stat dump:
The Altimer – Sam Isaacson, 2019
Length: 300 passages
Terminality (total): 7.67%
” (positive): 0.33% (ie how many passages give you victory)
” (negative): 7.33% (ie how many passages kill you)
Linearity: 34.33% (ie 103 passages/300 send you onwards without giving you any options)
Choice density: 1.82 options/passage
Choosability: 47.67% (ie on 143/300 passages, you get to choose your option freely)
Conditionality: 13.67% (ie on 41/300 passages, previous choices decide your next passage)
Chance index: 6.33% (ie on 19/300 passages, dice or another random factor decide your next passage)
Puzzle density: 0.33% or 1/300. Watch out here, as Sam grows to love a puzzle over his next books.
Choice Types:
Spatial / Action / Social = 72/46/25 /300 or 24% Spatial choices / 15.33% Action choices / 11.67% Social Choices
(Note that spatial is almost exactly equal to the total of Action + Social. Ie this book is largely a spatial puzzle, with some social interactions and a fair amount of activity options.
















