Guarded Location: Choice-Based Fiction Structure

I’m currently partway through playing and analysing Paul Partington’s Temple of the Skull God, a 2024 independent gamebook. It’s the subject of this month’s 100 Endings Reading Club on Discord and I’m using it as the third test case for a structural analysis I’m developing. It’s a great gamebook, with a clear debt to Fabled Lands and the open-world structure, a pirates/mesoamerican setting with perhaps the occasional escapee from Isla Nublar thrown in. There’s an elegant game system, called GNAT, codewords, tickboxes, an inventory of themed items – and not too many, either – and above all, it’s fun. It’s an adventure gamebook, not a reader-punishment tool or a painful proof of concept!

But while I’m logging all the conditions and links, I’ve noticed a neat and very efficient little pattern that Paul has used to build his world. In a gamebook like this, there has to be some system to govern re-visiting locations, but also something to make them feel memorable and distinct from one another. He does it like this:

What you’ve got here is a three-passage conditional guarded location. You can reach the location from multiple other passages and when you arrive, the first thing you read is a tickbox query. This is empty by default, so on you read.

In this sort of location, the author has stationed some sort of guard – a monster, animal or character who attacks the reader. A simple combat check (often as simple as the one illustrated here) has two outcomes: death – in which case, the adventure is over and no outward link is needed – or victory – in which case the box at the head of the passage is ticked and the player sent on to a subsequent passage. This follower (labelled A.2 in the top diagram) can describe how the guard is overcome, any side-effect on the player and then provide them with some reward for overcoming the enemy – loot of some kind. This passage is then really an event bundled into the location, and the original passage, which is a combat, is an event passage masquerading as a location.

A.2 concludes with options to travel on – normally a spatial choice – and fits back into the network of navigational passages that form an open world.

However, when revisiting Location A, the tickbox, which indicates that the guard has already been overcome and that the loot is already plundered (that’s efficient!) diverts the reader from A.1 to A.3, which is a vanilla location passage without any event, but with the same exit options as A.2.

It’s not rocket science but I think the lock on accessing the loot behind the guardian combat and the smoothness of the tickbox check make this among the most efficient possible ways to introduce guarded locations into an open-world gamebook. Paul uses it about 9 times in a 573-passage book, so it doesn’t become obvious and repetitive, and there are a few variations.

Anyway, it’s certainly a little piece I’ll consider employing myself on my next adventure in this style. Steam Highwayman doesn’t tend to have guards hanging around waiting for you to kill them and take their loot, but it really suits any sort of exploration adventure or dungeon.

If you’re interested in some of my other gamebook structure analyses, you could take a look at this post from February 2025, when I was thinking about Fetch Quests (and writing them into Princes of the West.

Thanks Skuldelev!

What’s going on here? A mock-up of the ‘shipsheet’ that will be part of a reader/player’s record-keeping for SAGA. The background image is a lightly-modified version of the plans of Skuldelev I, which, as every Viking enthusiast knows, is the wreck of the large, ocean-going knarr found at Skuldelev in Denmark. Historical accuracy is pretty key for my project, so why not go straight from archaeology to gameplay?

What sort of features will be included in your shipsheet? Well, the number of your crew is vital: all are assumed to be able to participate in a raid, even if you are sailing a trading knarr, like shown here. Some of these may be wounded in battle or accident, so that’s got to be recorded, although maybe not by name. Total food is a bit of duplicate – as a single vaett of food contains 40 matr, and 1 matr costs 1 penningr and should be enough to sustain a single crew-member for a month – and a vaett occupies a single ‘room’ or cargo space in the vessel. A voyage might last 3-6 months, in the current system. Other cargo spaces might be 1 vaett of beer, or iron ore, or amber, or 2 cattle, and so on.

Your two thegns are vital: their drengskapr, vel, vithirdugr and styrkr can replace or reinforce yours during skill checks; their hylli represents their loyalty and contentment with your leadership. They can also support you in battle, using unique tactics, and have their own story-goals, plot-lines and quests. Think of them as supporting characters, or key members of your party.

The length of your voyage and the time since your most recent raid will also feed into crew contentment, which should be checked fairly regularly. The longer you are away sailing, of course, the more you risk bad weather when you return home, and the more you risk missing your harvest, putting your winter food stores in danger. Pretty key statistics, then.

This all gives the book a real solo role-playing-game flavour, with so many details to track. Yet so far, I’m convinced I’m balancing this out with the depth and colour of the world and the stories that are being told within it. I’ll have to share some more of that soon, and take your input.

Alea iacta est.

Make a MOTORING roll of difficulty 13…

Three years ago when I first contemplated a Steam Highwayman Kickstarter, there were options for creating custom dice over the internet, but all amounted to ordering hundreds at a time in order to reach affordability. However, since then new manufacturers and middle-men have appeared on the internet and I’m in the process of designing and receiving prototypes for custom dice to accompany my books.

Custom dice have been one of the most-requested additions to my Kickstarter campaigns…

My current plan is to offer 2 custom Steam Highwayman dice as a reward bundle with re-drawn colour maps at around A2 size – watch out for a post about those coming soon. This means that long-time backers can receive the new Steam Highwayman volume with or without the additions, and any new backers can order all three volumes simply as books, or as a complete playing bundle.

Estimating the costs for custom dice is particularly difficult, as it’s hard to guess exactly how popular they’ll be. However I’m hoping to offer some stretch goals that could upgrade these packages, such as a pouch to keep the dice in, as well as extra features for the maps.

Either way, these little bones roll evenly and have been powering me through a current playthrough. I haven’t decided whether these will be the version available to backers, but the more I rattle them, the more I like them.

Steam Highwayman II Nearing Completion

That’s right.  If you’ve been following my Twitter updates or returning to look at the natty graph below, you’ve now that Steam Highwayman II: Highways and Holloways passed 1000 passages in draft a short while ago and has been accelerating onward.

I’m not planning on going on forever – in fact I mean to complete a few large quests that will help tie the whole book together and then call this draft finished.

What does that mean?  Well, I’ll be putting the book through an editing, proofing and checking process after that and then proceed to lay out the book interior – one of the jobs I enjoyed the most during SH1.  I’ve also been discussing and commissioning a cover design with Ben and have seen his first sketches.

A lot of what I used to get Steam Highwayman 1 published is still standing: I even have an ISBN number reserved for SH2.  Today I’ve been going over the numbers to plan a second Steam Highwayman Kickstarter to run during this summer.  Exactly when… will depend.

The Kickstarter will run much like the previous one, allowing keen backers to help contribute to the costs of the project, receive a written acknowledgement in the book and a copy ahead of general release.  However, I am discussing extra reward levels with Ben and am hoping to be able to reveal a particularly exciting way you could play a part in the book quite soon.  If there are things you’d like to see as part of the campaign, please let me know.

I’m hoping that a good proportion of my backers from KS1 will be keen to fund the sequel so they can expand their adventure, but I’m also hoping to broaden Steam Highwayman’s appeal to new readers, who will be able to receive copies of both books as rewards.

I received a nice message recently from a member of the online gamebook community who has been on a bit of a spree and bought SH1 online: his picture of Smog and Ambuscade and his comments really made my day.  If you’ve enjoyed volume 1 – and particularly if you bought it online – please recommend it with Amazon’s review system.  You don’t have to write a lot and you don’t have to have bought it through their shop, but online reviews are a really crucial part of increasing the project’s visibility.

The Spenser Cup – An Audio Adventure

Steam Highwayman now has an interactive Audio Adventure!  One of the most popular adventures within Smog and Ambuscade was the Spenser Cup, in which you must race a high-powered steam car, making tactical decisions as you ride.  I’ve narrated the sections and organised them so that your choices can string the events together into one story.  A different take on the ‘gamebook’ format: I’ve created the ‘gameaudiobook’.

Gamebook Page Mockup

I’ve been experimenting today with different styles of illustration and layout, using Microsoft Publisher and my own two hands (though mainly the right one). Result: a mockup that resembles a page of my finished gamebook.  Illustrations all my own, with Mitsubishi uniball micro.  Font is Georgia: nicely serifed, not too full-on.