Guarded Location: Choice-Based Fiction Structure

I’m currently partway through playing and analysing Paul Partington’s Temple of the Skull God, a 2024 independent gamebook. It’s the subject of this month’s 100 Endings Reading Club on Discord and I’m using it as the third test case for a structural analysis I’m developing. It’s a great gamebook, with a clear debt to Fabled Lands and the open-world structure, a pirates/mesoamerican setting with perhaps the occasional escapee from Isla Nublar thrown in. There’s an elegant game system, called GNAT, codewords, tickboxes, an inventory of themed items – and not too many, either – and above all, it’s fun. It’s an adventure gamebook, not a reader-punishment tool or a painful proof of concept!

But while I’m logging all the conditions and links, I’ve noticed a neat and very efficient little pattern that Paul has used to build his world. In a gamebook like this, there has to be some system to govern re-visiting locations, but also something to make them feel memorable and distinct from one another. He does it like this:

What you’ve got here is a three-passage conditional guarded location. You can reach the location from multiple other passages and when you arrive, the first thing you read is a tickbox query. This is empty by default, so on you read.

In this sort of location, the author has stationed some sort of guard – a monster, animal or character who attacks the reader. A simple combat check (often as simple as the one illustrated here) has two outcomes: death – in which case, the adventure is over and no outward link is needed – or victory – in which case the box at the head of the passage is ticked and the player sent on to a subsequent passage. This follower (labelled A.2 in the top diagram) can describe how the guard is overcome, any side-effect on the player and then provide them with some reward for overcoming the enemy – loot of some kind. This passage is then really an event bundled into the location, and the original passage, which is a combat, is an event passage masquerading as a location.

A.2 concludes with options to travel on – normally a spatial choice – and fits back into the network of navigational passages that form an open world.

However, when revisiting Location A, the tickbox, which indicates that the guard has already been overcome and that the loot is already plundered (that’s efficient!) diverts the reader from A.1 to A.3, which is a vanilla location passage without any event, but with the same exit options as A.2.

It’s not rocket science but I think the lock on accessing the loot behind the guardian combat and the smoothness of the tickbox check make this among the most efficient possible ways to introduce guarded locations into an open-world gamebook. Paul uses it about 9 times in a 573-passage book, so it doesn’t become obvious and repetitive, and there are a few variations.

Anyway, it’s certainly a little piece I’ll consider employing myself on my next adventure in this style. Steam Highwayman doesn’t tend to have guards hanging around waiting for you to kill them and take their loot, but it really suits any sort of exploration adventure or dungeon.

If you’re interested in some of my other gamebook structure analyses, you could take a look at this post from February 2025, when I was thinking about Fetch Quests (and writing them into Princes of the West.

Update 13 – You must never break the chain

That’s the chain of updates, of course.  But also, in a moment of genuine inspiration, I created a unique marker that unlocks several parts of the Smuggling Module (Q1h/Q165) – the chain tattoo that you gain, involuntarily, after completing your smuggling training with the Terror, Terence Kneebone, aboard his steam crester, the Swell Dolly.

Who is the Steam Highwayman?  A free adventurer, bound to no-one, riding wherever you will…  Until you accept something like Penrose’s ring or the chain tattoo and you become associated with a dreaming visionary revolutionary or a ruthless smuggler.

This last two weeks I’ve been working almost entirely on the smuggling module.  I thought I could write a short series of passages, but to balance out the scale of the trade network I’ve already built for firkins of brandy and the like, I have needed some size, length and openness.  In a way, I’ve rebuilt something like the open-sea module, but without as much freedom.  Yet I’ve still needed some passage extensions to the book to fit in what’s needed.

How does it work?  Well, that all depends where you are.  In Devon, you’ll simply need to find some smugglers on the North or South coast, win their trust, hire them to sail with you, head out to a rendezvous on a foreign shore or at sea, buy contraband and then bring it to a depot point, put it ashore, return to your port, head to your depot, get your contraband aboard your velosteam – provided you have your barrel panniers fitted – be lucky enough to escape the attention of the Constables, bring your cargo to a buyer, like a friendly landlord, avoid narks, get a good price and repeat.  Information regarding most of this – rendezvous points, willing smugglers, innkeepers happy to buy and places where you can hide your goods – is readily available as a series of rumours you’ll hear in pubs, freight yards or on the road.

And in Cornwall?  It’s complicated by the Imperial Blockade, which is meant to stop small craft bringing goods into Cornwall, so you’ll need to be lucky in avoiding their ships, or have money for bribes, or a fearless crew ready to fight, or perhaps a craft that can submerge…  And then, once ashore, your sale of spirits is carefully observed by the gangs answering to Bad Percy and the Terror – so you’ll need to pay a share whenever you do sell some barrels, cutting into your profits.

And of course, you’ll need to wear the chain tattoo to gain the trust of anyone in the network.

If it sounds complex, it is.  There are around thirty codewords that track your access to rendezvous and depot locations, the availability of the six different vessels you can sail with and the attitudes of the gangs towards you.  There are around thirty rumours that carry information about it all – and although the module is mostly standalone, it ties in, of course, with several of the key dynamics of the Rebellion.  After all, liquor is not the only contraband you can smuggle into Free Cornwall.

Why bother?  Wasn’t the book almost finished already?  Well, Cornwall without smuggling would be like a pasty without pastry – it would always have been a massive regret.  And to do it well, as I mentioned above, when there is now a network of around forty places wanting to buy your firkins of gin or lace scarves, I needed something semi-open.  I’ve done my best to limit the size and repetitiveness of the strands, but I’ve also accepted that the book will be massively improved by something that is at my standard of ‘good-enough’ – I don’t need to invent new mechanics to solve this.  Hence the proliferation of codewords, when instead some sort of map-based solution has occasionally suggested itself to me.

This is going to greatly alter the balance of the book.  The amount of money that can be made is large – as long as you have capital.  It increases the danger that Terence Kneebone poses and embroils you deeper in his nefarious network.  Who is the Steam Highwayman? In Cornwall, a smuggler of unlicensed brandy, steaming along clifftops with the Constables in pursuit, just as the place demands.

So since last update I have:

  • Fixed a roadside encounter with poor workmanship
  • Written a new pub in Helston
  • Completed Q11 – the orchestral airship quest.  This is a fun one reminiscent of the airship quests in Highways & Holloways.
  • Planned more than 200 passages of the smuggling module
  • Written around 70 passages of the module

And what next?  In the next fortnight I aim to:

  • Finish the smuggling module!

Next update due: 21.11.25

Book of Legends

Online chat has unearthed another open-world gamebook project that launched in 2023, but seems to have hidden beneath the radar for a little while. Book of Legends: The Eternal Empire is the Prologue Volume (that’s book 0 in a projected 10-book series) by Steven W Huggins.

Let’s not deny that a 10-book series is an ambitious undertaking – yet the 200-passage sample has already impressed me. It has a self-contained, explorable region that gives a great introduction to a world of fantastical-extended-Roman-empire that I find pretty original, while also feeling reminiscent of the Sorcery books. A colossal amount of work has gone into preparing the ground for a big series – there are around 50 pages of rules, mechanics and introduction in a 152-page printed copy – and the attention to detail is convincing. Huggins has also used a variety of mechanics – codewords, tickboxes and time-counters – to create an environment that responds and changes as you explores it – which is where the reminiscence to The Seven Serpents particularly comes in.

Online the author talks of being deep into the first volume – and veterans know that when publishing a series, a gamebook author should really be using a formula like (estimated time of writing) x 2 + 2 years. But I think this is one that I will be following…

Speaking of open-world series, Dave Morris is talking of completing the Vulcanverse saga… I’ve been working today on a long series of articles on How to Write an Open-World Gamebook (Series) [link coming when completed!] since they’ve been requested plenty of times, and I haven’t even ventured into the Vulcanverse, let alone mapped them! Book of Legends 0, on the other hand, has been a nice little mapping project.